Agave palmeri

Submitted by DesertZone on

Anyone out there with Agave palmeri in colder climates?

Here is a big one near Old Pearce AZ

Comments


Submitted by Weiser on Sat, 11/26/2011 - 22:50

Aaron
That is one hell of an agave! :o Is it yours?

I grow a palmeri it's no were near as large as the one in your photo. Mine is about five years old and pupping a little. I hear they can go rampant and take over or invade choice neighbors.


Submitted by Martin Tversted on Sun, 11/27/2011 - 00:22

I have grown this one and its one of my favorites. And it doesnt survive here nt even in the unheated greenhouse. Only have moderate succes with havardiana, utahensis types, gracilipes, parryi and a few others. Maybe I should try again again again

Martin


Submitted by DesertZone on Sun, 11/27/2011 - 08:47

Martin wrote:

I have grown this one and its one of my favorites. And it doesnt survive here nt even in the unheated greenhouse. Only have moderate succes with havardiana, utahensis types, gracilipes, parryi and a few others. Maybe I should try again again again

Martin

Hi, what zone are you in? or area?
I would love to try one from higher elev.  I have seen them grow at about 7000ft but I can't seem to find any seed. >:(  Sounds like you are doing good with some others.  I have never had any success with havardiana so I bet if a person could find it from higher up I bet they could do well.


Submitted by DesertZone on Sun, 11/27/2011 - 08:58

Weiser wrote:

Aaron
That is one hell of an agave! :o Is it yours?

I grow a palmeri it's no were near as large as the one in your photo. Mine is about five years old and pupping a little. I hear they can go rampant and take over or invade choice neighbors.

I wish it was mine, it was  on a couple of lots away from mine I don't seem to have any on my place...one right over the fence but... :D

You say yours is pupping?  I dont think I have ever seen them pup in the wild.  I have a small high elev. parryi that has a small pup, would you like to make a trade next spring?


Submitted by penstemon on Sun, 11/27/2011 - 09:00

Growing it for now, if that counts.....

Bob


Submitted by Weiser on Sun, 11/27/2011 - 09:17

DesertZone wrote:

[ I have a small high elev. parryi that has a small pup, would you like to make a trade next spring?

Aaron check your Email ;) The answer is Yes. ;D

Nold wrote:

Growing it for now, if that counts.....

Bob

Any thing you grow counts in my book!! 8)


Submitted by DesertZone on Sun, 11/27/2011 - 09:33

Now here is one in a garden in Elfrida AZ that has pups, but I wonder if it is its close cousin Agave chrysantha?
I don't know that much about agave. ;)


Submitted by penstemon on Sun, 11/27/2011 - 09:54

The palmeri I got will soon be that size, no doubt ...
I got mine free, as a trial. I think seed came from the Chiricahuas. Or some place reasonably high. We'll see.

Bob


Submitted by DesertZone on Sun, 11/27/2011 - 09:58

Nold wrote:

The palmeri I got will soon be that size, no doubt ...
I got mine free, as a trial. I think seed came from the Chiricahuas. Or some place reasonably high. We'll see.

Bob

Good deal! That is where I seen them at higher up. ;)


Submitted by DesertZone on Sun, 11/27/2011 - 10:16

Hey, anyone out there that wants some dasylirion w. seed I still have some from a plant close to this one. ;)


Submitted by penstemon on Sun, 11/27/2011 - 17:06

The "woody lilies" are all very easy from seed, but getting them from there to the garden and having their little rear ends frozen off is not a happy journey.
I would hold off planting seed grown agaves, yuccas, dasylirions, and nolinas for at least a few years. They all overwinter as house plants very nicely. (This from someone who can barely get a philodendron to grow.)
Another ploy is to spray them with an antidesiccant like Cloud Cover. Yes, coating them with plastic.....

Bob


Submitted by DesertZone on Sat, 12/03/2011 - 12:48

Weiser wrote:

Aaron check your Email ;) The answer is Yes. ;D

I have recived a great gift!  Thanks again John. :)

I wont forget next spring to send that pup off and anything else you might want?


Submitted by penstemon on Sat, 12/03/2011 - 16:53

My palmeri is under about 5 inches of snow right now. Or it might not be, there's an incense cedar in front of it and maybe the snow didn't land on the agave. I don't feel like going out and looking.
Snow on marginally hardy succulents is a mixed blessing.

Maybe I'll go cover it before it gets completely dark. 

Bob


Submitted by DesertZone on Sat, 12/03/2011 - 17:48

Nold wrote:

Snow on marginally hardy succulents is a mixed blessing.

Bob

I agree, I have more things die from snow cover than cold.  Makes the yuccas, agave, and cactus rot around here.


Submitted by penstemon on Sat, 12/03/2011 - 21:17

Quote:

I have more things die from snow cover than cold.  Makes the yuccas, agave, and cactus rot around here. 

Same here.
Though, if it's cold when the snow falls, and the snow is "dry", then there's less trouble. It's when the snow "melts" (really, evaporates) but not quite completely, then more snow falls, that spells doom.
Another thing that's a killer is a layer of ice right on the ground. That's only happened here once. It killed everything from South Africa, killed a lot of cactus, too.
I went out and put a small piece of frost fabric over Agave palmeri. I could have kept the plant indoors for a few winters, but it was free, so I figure, what the heck.

Bob


Submitted by Hoy on Sun, 12/04/2011 - 07:14

DesertZone wrote:

Hey, anyone out there that wants some dasylirion w. seed I still have some from a plant close to this one. ;)

Aaron, do you still have some seed? I would love to try! Don't know what to trade with - not many desert plants here ;)

Dry snow cover? ??? Here the snow is always wet . . . .
Although I am familiar with dry snow cover in the mountains. At our cabin we prefere a thick snow cower.


Submitted by DesertZone on Sun, 12/04/2011 - 08:14

Hoy wrote:

Aaron, do you still have some seed? I would love to try! Don't know what to trade with - not many desert plants here ;)

Dry snow cover? ??? Here the snow is always wet . . . .
Although I am familiar with dry snow cover in the mountains. At our cabin we prefere a thick snow cower.

I still have some, just pm your address. ;)

It get so clod here that the snow falls very dry and can not pack together. 


Submitted by penstemon on Sun, 12/04/2011 - 08:16

Quote:

 Dry snow cover?

Yes, dry. If the ground is dry before it snows, and the snow doesn't melt (which it rarely does here from about now until February...it evaporates, technically, sublimates), then the plants are not wet, just cold.
If it rains first, or the snow is not quite frozen when it first falls, and more snow falls on top of that, then it's time to order new plants ...
As far as I'm aware, agaves and their relatives have no mechanism for moisture loss that allows them to endure subfreezing temperatures. There are a number of species that routinely experience temperatures of -10C (note, celsius) in the wild, but none that experience temperatures much colder than that. I imagine that the species that do infrequently see -17C have evolved some sort of way of increasing the sugar solution to lower the freezing point of the water in their leaves, but I don't know what it is, and don't know of any studies.
I might ask around.
The coldest temperature I've been able to find for the Chihuahuan Desert is -30C at Villa Ahumada in Chihuahua. But not every winter.
Does that make sense?
Here is Agave havardiana (or the tips of it anyway), same plants I photographed a week or so ago, this morning. These plants come from the Davis Mountains in western Texas. Still not a very cold place, but maybe just cold enough. We'll see.

Bob


Submitted by DesertZone on Sun, 12/04/2011 - 08:34

Bob, makes total sense.


Submitted by Weiser on Sun, 12/04/2011 - 09:06

What's this talk of snow?  ;)
We have been dry and cold since the the beginning of November. Just a little on the top of the Sierras. It could change very quickly though. In truth, I hope it dose, water is always at a premium no matter what form it takes.  8)


Submitted by DesertZone on Sun, 12/04/2011 - 15:43

Weiser wrote:

water is always at a premium no matter what form it takes.  8)

I agree, as much as I dont like it we need all we can get.


Submitted by penstemon on Sun, 12/04/2011 - 16:11

Quote:

What's this talk of snow? 

 

Though a lot of residents will deny it, Denver has nine months of snow. It snows at the slightest provocation, and this is possibly the only place on the planet where the forecast has been 85F (29.4C) with snow at night.
It snows here more than it does in Minneapolis. I counted over one hundred separate snowfalls between Sept. 1st and June 1st one year. Every time you turn around, it's snowing.

Bob


Submitted by Lori S. on Sun, 12/04/2011 - 16:35

Calgary's weather patterns are similar... it's nice to live close to the mountains but, boy, they do mess up the weather!  We sometimes get snow in June, and snow in September is common... but on the other hand, I would find it far too depressing to claim we have ten months of snow.  ;D ;D


Submitted by penstemon on Sun, 12/04/2011 - 16:43

As long as I see hellebores and snowdrops blooming in January, I guess I don't care.

How's that collection for my villa on the Italian Rivera coming?

Bob


Submitted by penstemon on Thu, 12/08/2011 - 09:28

Just looked at my Agave palmeri after our cold snap. It's NDY. (Not Dead Yet.)

Bob


Submitted by Hoy on Fri, 12/09/2011 - 07:25

DesertZone wrote:

Bob, makes total sense.

Yes, perfectly.

DesertZone wrote:

Weiser wrote:

water is always at a premium no matter what form it takes.  8)

I agree, as much as I dont like it we need all we can get.

Not me. I would prefere much less of the stuff especially in fall and winter. My friends would say much less in summer too ;)


Submitted by penstemon on Sun, 12/18/2011 - 10:00

Now it's dead. Or doomed.
Odd that this is a "high elevation form" (Chiricahuas) and yet A. parryi var. huachucensis (Huachucas) is perfectly hardy here. According to Nobel (Environmental Biology of Agaves and Cacti) the laboratory results of cold hardiness tests of these two taxa are roughly the same.
I'll try palmeri again next year.

Bob


Submitted by DesertZone on Sun, 12/18/2011 - 14:50

Here's a pic of one from high in the chiricahua nat'l mon., looks very different than the ones in the valley.  Maybe its something different?